Search

Does Martyrdom Prove A Belief To Be True?

Many Christians, myself included, believe that the willingness of Jesus' early followers to face martyrdom rather than deny Him is evidence that the Jesus story was true.

However, many skeptics point out that other faiths, like Muslims, Buddhists, and even extremist faiths like the Branch Davidians, were willing to die for their faiths.  So does this willingness make their beliefs true as well?

The difference is that the earliest Christians were in a position to know for a fact whether Jesus was resurrected or not.  If Jesus wasn't resurrected, then it's very unlikely that they could have mistakenly thought He was, and been so sure that He was that they would die rather than deny it.  People of the other faiths aren't in such a position.  They either believe in things that happened centuries ago, or things that they didn't personally witness.

Willingness to die for their beliefs is, no doubt, evidence that they honestly believe in what they claim.  The difference is that, with the earliest Christians, they were in the unique position of knowing whether it was true or not.

Please log in to post comments. Not a member? Register. It's free!